Netanyahu Improves the Prospects of Reaching a Deal with the Palestinians

I don't normally blog just about Israeli politics — generally, I prefer to write about things where there is some kind of Torah angle or connection — but there is a recent political development in Israel that is VERY important, that I think a lot of people might have missed.

I have to admit, that until now, I have not been very impressed with Netanyahu.  Despite his much criticized partial freeze on construction in the settlements — criticized by the right, by the left, and by the Palestinians (albeit for different reasons!) — I didn't think he was serious about trying to put together a deal with the Palestinians.  I figured it was a manuever to get the Americans off his back, and that's it.  I figured if he ever got close to being serious about putting together a deal with the Palestinians, it would never happen, because if he made the compromises necessary to make a deal, the right wing of his narrow coalition would bolt, his government would collapse, and that would be the end of that.

Yesterday's Israeli papers reported on some political manuevering that could completely change that assessment.

As reported yesterday in Haaretz, Netanyahu has told Kadima head Tzipi Livni that if she doesn't join his coalition, he will split her party (truthfully, more like destroy her party).  As was reported in Haaretz a few days earlier, it looks like Netanyahu would not have a lot of trouble attracting the seven Kadima MKs needed to allow them to split off as a separate faction and join the coalition without Livni.

Livni is really in a box.  I hope she'll decide to bring Kadima into the coaltion and form a unity government.  That would be the strongest possible basis for putting together a real peace deal, and it would be the only way to preserve Kadima as a viable party going forward.  Unfortunately, in the past she seems to have allowed her ego to stand in the way of what was best for the country (and probably best for her as well) so I'm not optimistic that this will happen.

But either way, Netanyahu is going to shore up his government with more ministers who will support putting together a deal with the Palestinians.  Right now, the parties in the government that would clearly support doing a deal with the Palestinians even if it means giving up a lot of territory are Likud, Labor, and Yisrael Beiteinu — which represent a total of 55 seats in the Knesset.  Not enough to form a government.  If the more right wing parties in the coalition bolted, it likely would have meant the collapse of the government.

But if Netayahu picks up seven "renegade" Kadima MKs, the presumptive supporters of a deal number 62 — a very narrow government, but enough to prevent the government from collapsing.  Enough to make it much likelier that the government could actually put together a deal with the Palestinians.

This is going to be a very interesting time.  Surprising things could happen, but Netanyahu seems to be holding the strongest cards at the moment.  Possible scenarios:

  • Kadima joins the government, providing a very broad-based coalition supporting making a deal with the Palestinians
  • Netanyahu splits Kadima, picks up 7 to 10 new members of coalition, and is still able to proceed, although perhaps a little more cautiously
  • I suppose it's theoretically possible that the right wing parties could try and collapse the government right now, before Netanyahu could put together a deal with Kadima or the "renegades." But that doesn't seem real likely, and I have no idea whether the timing, etc., is such that such a strategy could work anyway. And what would the right wing parties do then?  Make a deal with Kadima?
  • Least likely scenario in my opinion is that Livni manages to impose some sort of "party discipline" and reel the "renegades" in.  Seems least likely because she has made a lot of enemies.

There are those criticizing Netanyahu's moves — asking questions like whether offering the "renegades" cabinet level posts is tantamount to "bribery" — but I have to say it looks like very astute political manuevering on his part, and since it's maneuvering that could lead to a greater chance for putting together a real peace deal with the Palestinians, I'm all in favor of it.

Interesting times we're living in…

Reb Barry


Barry Leff

Rabbi Barry (Baruch) Leff is a dual Israeli-American business executive, teacher, speaker and writer who divides his time between Israel and the US.

One thought on “Netanyahu Improves the Prospects of Reaching a Deal with the Palestinians

  • January 3, 2010 at 1:39 pm

    Add to that the very interesting comment made today by Abbas and the Egyptian government that Netanyahu has made some “serious proposals” indicating to them that he is serious about making a peace deal……..yep, I think he wants Kadima mavericks to keep his government in power when he announces that we are pulling out of some of the settlements and some of East Jerusalem, and then his Right wing will leave the government.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Keep me up to date, sign me up for the newsletter!